Doug
Like you I try a bit of everything - tab, notation and chords
I tend to play for my own pleasure so I like to strum a chord progression - indeed most of my posting are about chord progressions. i did a load of posts on strum patterns a while back. they had to beg me to stop
and that is indeed is what chordie is best for. if you want the chord progressions then this is the place. lyrics and chords on one page. all neatly transposed. its a great resource. and i like the people here.
however strumming through an entire set list can get boring. the ramones sounds rather like Joni mitchell if you just do up down strums. so i learn the rythym and a couple of fills and the licks. often its just the strum pattern and a minor embelishment. a chord with a pedal note, a bit of damping or a run between chord changes. powertabs is good for that. especially if you want to arrange a piece yourself
in any case we have the MPA doing a bit of book burning. stopping people sharing tabs. I think thats a bad thing. as a community we have to be aware of that.
tab librarys settled with the MPA and is back on line - but i imagine it needs visitors to stay free to all. the adverts pay the MPA. so I expect its a case of use or lose it, folks.
they'll be coming for the goatskins next
as to notation i learnt piano as a child so i can read music but i can't read chord notation. i tried once. i can recognise a c chord !
but not only are chords tough in notation - but if you are going to play rawk or even pop you probably want to know the position. so many songs are played by sliding down and up the fret board using a barre shape (well they are when I play them !)
however I hate not knowing what key I'm playing in. thats a notation thing. tab doesn't give you that. I find knowing the expected chords in a key is the best aid to memorising the progression. if youre in the key of C you are likely to have F and G somewhere. if you don't the songwriters up to something. what is he up to ? is it minor. or has he added a blues chord. those are all aids to memorising the progression.
cheers
john