Hello juliamarie - and touche'! My comments were made in jest . . . I started my discovery of music playing bassoon. I also played braritone sax in the stage band in high school.
Even though I could read and play all the notes on the page, I never could improvise on the sax (or bassoon) - I just couldn't make that leap of faith off the written page.
Went off to college thinking I wanted to be a Music major, but soon realized that I did not have the dedication to spend at least 4 hours in a practice room every day perfecting my technique - so I switched majors and music became a hobby rather than a career goal.
I love classical (or "serious" music) and am lucky to live in a small town that has a major univeristy, so we can hear accomplished musicians ply their trade.
However; I see an irony in that most classically-trained musicians are incapable (or unwilling) to step out and improvise. They are excellent technicians, but seemingly lacking in the spark it takes to play music that is not written.
On the other hand, there are the vast hordes of self-taught musicians who love to improvise but who are unable (or are uninterested in learning how) to read music.
I believe that anybody who enjoys making music will benefit from learning as much as they can about how to do it better. If you know the technical stuff - then learn how to play beyond the written notes. If you already don't require written notes - then learn how to read music and whole new world of wonderment will open to you.
I've got a good friend who plays cello and I've been trying to get him to play with me - but he is terrified of not having a full bass line written out. . . I'll keep working on him though and wear him down eventually.
"That darn Pythagorean Comma thing keeps messing me up!"
[url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagorean_comma[/url]