Re: Prog Rock Wednesdays
Good Choices.
You are not logged in. Please login or register.
Guitar chord forum - chordie → Bands and artists → Prog Rock Wednesdays
Good Choices.
Spent a little time tonight catching up on PRW. Some really great stuff that I haven't heard for a very long time.
But I especially enjoyed ELP's "Take a Pebble" Thanks for a long ago discarded memory TF
.
EDIT: I should pay attention to spellcheck
TF: Will you forgive me the fact the only song which totally rocked me was "Today's Tom Sawyer"?
I know. It's a "reach" for this 66 year-old drummer, but it sure made me wish I could have been Neal Peart slamming away at that wonderful kit.
I cannot compare these three to my beloved ELP, but I certainly DO also appreciate the talents of Messrs Geddy Lee Alex Lifeson and Neal Peart .
Maybe I just came along a little late?
Your Friend
PS: Got a little Klaatu, for me?
PSS: Alex's Accptance Speech: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-zV4GaElko
I love you guys (And Ladies ----- no "GALS" remember?)
BC
"Tom Sawyer" had been the opening tune for most of their live shows for many years, and proved to be the perfect adenalin-boost to get the crowd into the concert. It's a fairly easy song to play, and those opening E5 - D5 - A7sus4 - Csus2 chords sound really good, with a cranked-up bridge humbucker smacking into those preamp tubes, for some solid gain & sustain.
No surprise that it's a favorite track with many Rush fans, including yourself!
I haven't seen any live Klaatu on YouTube, but I had their album "Hope" many years ago ... don't know where it ended up. Wasn't there a rumour circulating in the 70's, that Klaatu were really an anonymous reincarnation of The Beatles?
Spent a little time tonight catching up on PRW. Some really great stuff that I haven't heard for a very long time.
But I especially enjoyed ELP's "Take a Pebble" Thanks for a long ago discarded memory TF
EDIT: I should pay attention to spellcheck
Thanks, UJB! In addition to the classic stuff from those "formative years", I've been equally pleased with a lot of the newer Prog groups that have come into being in this century. Nice to know that good music genres don't disappear, even if many of the originators aren't performing their material any more. That said, there will never be another ELP, Jethro Tull, Pink Floyd, or Yes ... they stand apart as unique. Steven Wilson is (IMHO) heads & shoulders above most of this newer crew ... just plain "Wow!"
King Crimson "Easy Money" Japan, 2015
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eOdk015mLEo
Here's another selection from KC's recent "Radical Action ..." DVD. Interesting time signatures. Robert Fripp (far right) is his usually formal self, and his creativity with guitar + electronics is in full evidence, even though he looks like a guy who's about to do your tax return. Jakko Jackzyk is in fine voice, and the percussion trio offers a fresh perspective ... no rules, once again.
"In The Court Of The Crimson King" was always one of my favorites, TF, but I wasn't familiar with "Easy Money" until today and loved it, but THREE drummers (am I seeing that correctly?)???? I have to say I'm impressed! Are they all independently wealthy? Like you said, "no rules".
Also, as regards Marillion: I heard a song by them while vacationing in Germany several years ago, but can't remember the name of it. Did it have a lady's name?
Thanks,
Bill
PS: "In A Gadda Da Vida". Useless trivia, but I read somewhere that the name came from a mispronounced title of "In The Garden Of Eden". Apparently, the lead singer was so hung over, he mumbled the song's title and that's what came out of his mouth.
Another bit of trivia: Someone apparently started the rumor that "In A Gadda Da Vida" was Yiddish for "In The Garden Of Love". When I heard that, I laughed so hard my belly hurt! Yiddish???!!.....
Thanks, Bill ... glad you enjoyed it.
King Crimson: There's no doubt that they have been a major influence since their original incarnation n 1968. Some notables onstage here are bassist Tony Levin, who has played with so many well-known musicians it would be impossible to list them. Also of note is drummer Gavin Harrison (on the right, audience view) formerly of Porcupine Tree.
Marillion: I consider these guys "pop prog", as they have bridged the gap nicely between true prog creativity, with a broader pop audience appeal. That's no small feat, and kudos to them for succeeding at it. The only song of theirs I can think of with a lady's name is "Kayleigh", from their 1985 album "Misplaced Childhood". It was released as a single (which is probably why it's better known) and featured former lead vocalist Derek Dick (a.k.a. "Fish"). I tend to prefer their later material, after Steve Hogarth replaced Fish in 1988. That said, their material is all quite good, from both eras.
Iron Butterfly: The story of the botched name is true, according to their drummer Ron Bushy. Singer Doug Ingle was apparently blind drunk when he told Bushy the song's name, and that's how it was printed. Not every famous idea is well-planned!
Premiata Forneria Marconi "La Carozza di Hans" Japan, 2002
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fnp2mYMOqjI
Still together and performing since 1970, only drummer Franz Di Cioccio and bassist Patrick Djivas remain from the early days. PFM are easily the best Prog band to come out of Italy, and bring a tremendous amount of passion to their live performances. I only discovered them a few years ago, and have been amazed by the high quality of their work, as well as the sheer volume (18 studio albums, 14 live albums, plus compilations). The band's name translated means "Marconi's Award-Winning Bakery" ... for which I can find no explanation. I love it because it seems to make no sense whatsoever!
This track is from their first album "Storia di un Minuto", released in 1972.
Tangerine Dream "Jungle Voice" Lisbon, 2010
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPK1NV4bXqA
The Lisbon concert was one TD's most ambitious, delivering a full 3 hrs + 21 mins of music. They featured a broad spectrum of their material (over 100 albums / CDs released since they began) with much of it adapted and re-worked as bands will often do. This piece features a rare vocal element, and showcases percussionist Iris Camaa's talent. Her percussive skills and stage presence add a greater audience appeal than TD was once know for, although some stalwart TD fans don't always approve. Enjoy!
Marillion "Brave" Minehead, England, 2005
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tn9sI9wTz8
This highly atmospheric piece is the title track from Marillion's 1994 album of the same name, released in 1994. It has a very airy, Celtic feel, and Steve Hogarth's vocal abilities are captivating. Here's the story behind this beautiful concept album:
"Brave is a concept album, based on a news story Steve Hogarth heard on the radio about a girl who was taken into police custody, after being found wandering the Severn Bridge. She did not know who she was, where she came from, and refused to even speak. This inspired Hogarth to write a fictional story about this girl, and what might have led to her being on the Severn Bridge in this state."
Much of the album was recorded in a castle in France to capture suitable acoustics, with many of the album's background sounds recorded in a large cave nearby. I have this 2-CD digitally remastered edition, and it is bonafide headphone music.
Richard Wright & David Gilmour "Breakthrough" London, 2002
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Rnn2cV9NHA
Here's another beautiful piece by the late Richard Wright, from his 1996 solo album "Broken China". He only did one other solo album (Wet Dream, 1978), and ultimately passed away in 2008. Richard's wife suffered with mental illness (as did former band-mate Syd Barrett) and it's easy to hear Wright's heart & soul in most of his solo work. "Breakthrough" is one of 16 tracks from the album, and it's all wonderfully written music with deep feelings throughout. On a separate note, this clip really makes me want to learn how to play the cello!
Yes "The Fish (Schindleria Praematurus)" Montreux, Switzerland, 2003
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FHFox6wyXfw
Here's the late Chris Squire, and his famous bass solo piece. Chris earned the nickname "Fish" because he spent too much time in the bathtub, when they were sharing hotel rooms on the road. He left his signature influence on what could be done with a bass guitar, and the unique tones he got from his stereo Rickenbacker are amazing. In one of the online "rig rundowns", he spoke about having one feed go directly to his Ampeg bass stack for a pure, deep bass sound. The other channel was routed through his effects board to a second amp stack, so he could produce the modified sound alongside the pure tone, without sacrificing either. "The Fish" was first featured on the group's 1972 album "Fragile", and became a regular feature in their concerts.
Sadly, we'll never hear Chris play this again ... thank goodness for YouTube!
Quidam "SurREvival" Oskard, 2010
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbH7qPTNQr4
Not to be confused with the Cirque du Soleil production of the same name, Quidam is another terrific prog group from Poland. This live concert was shot in Oskard in 2009, and released as a 2-disk DVD set in 2010. The whole group displays excellent musicianship, and are as tight together as any 6 or 7 piece ensemble could hope to be. Violinist Tylda Ciolkosz hammers home her solo contributions, and the sum of the various parts is delicious. Although Quidam haven't toured much outside their local area, their music has won critical acclaim, and prog lovers (like me) continue to hope for more.
I had never heard of them before - very good musicians. Great song
Thanks for the enlightenment
Jim
Thanks, TIG / Jim ...
I don't get many comments on this thread, and realize that Prog isn't most people's cup o' tea. This is as much personal therapy as anything, and I'm glad you enjoyed it. And I agree ... these guys are great musicians ... solid timing.
I like some of the Prog you have listed. You have to appreciate the musical ability of many of the player and some will play guitar, a horn, and a violin in the same song. With that kind of talent I thought more would listen to them. I have listened to some you have listed and some sound better than others and all of them are interesting.
Where do you find them to list. Is there a Prog radio station where you live?
Thanks, CG ...
Most of these selections are from groups I'm familiar with, and I've also amassed quite a CD collection of Prog Rock over the years. There are several Prog websites I visit and have learned about new groups, and have made some nice discoveries that way. I've kept a log of who/what I list each week to avoid duplication, and have now posted 149 entries without having scratched the surface yet. It needs to be said, that I certainly wouldn't say that Prog musicians are any better than anyone else, or that their compositions are any better. I just happen to like most of it ... it holds my attention.
Our fellow-Chordian "Badeye" (Friday Blues Fix) is now in his 10th year of weekly entries, and he continues to amaze me with the variety and quality of blues he finds. And while blues is not my first choice of style, there is certainly an amazing wealth of talent in that genre. Blues guitar has likely influenced more of modern music than any other, with classical being perhaps the only contender.
Marillion "Three Minute Boy" Zelande, Netherlands, 2011
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpTf4dBlAHM
Here's a candidate for the "Best Audience Participation" award, if there is such a thing. Singer Steve Hogarth has a real knack for audience chemistry, and these "Marillion Weekends" are a unique event they've been doing for several years with great success. And as a guitarist, Steve Rothery's solo (begins at around 4:10) is amazing. The big man sure knows his way around a fretboard, and is - IMHO - terribly unknown and under-rated. The fickleness of the pop music industry is well expressed in this song, which is a track from their 1998 CD entitled "Radiation".
Pink Floyd "On the Turning Away" New York, 1988
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZLuDvN7W0c
The 1988 live album "Delicate Sound of Thunder" was compiled from shows in New York, and engineered at Abbey Rd. This particular song is from their 1987 album "A Momentary Lapse of Reason". This was one of the three post-Roger Waters albums, which I feel were just as good as their previous ones ... this song is further evidence. The solo portion (second half of song) is a showcase for the amazing Fender "Fat 50's" pickups, my favorite single-coil pups of all time. They solo clearly and growl loudly!
Quidam "Alone Together" Oskard, 2010
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNNuQSan5_E
Another quieter, moody piece from Quidam's "Strong Together" live DVD, with a Celtic feel. Love this group! This is the title track from their 2009 CD ... very compelling artwork:
Genesis "Dancing With the Moonlit Knight" Shepperton, Surrey, England, 1973
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPm62PqLk34
Here's Peter Gabriel at the height of his theatrical self. His predisposition for this kind of thing made keyboardist Tony Banks and bassist Mike Rutherford quite uneasy, and in most live film from this era, you'll often find them exchanging disapproving glances while Peter was goofing off. Their 1973 album "Selling England by the Pound" featured this song, as well as some of the best music of that incarnation of the group.
Of particular note is a few segments where guitarist Steve Hackett is seen doing what we now call "tapping" (he called it "nailing"). He was the first guitarist to employ this technique, which is also heard on their 1971 album "Nursery Cryme". Later guitarists used it with greater abundance, most notably Eddie Van Halen. In an interview, Eddie declared that Hackett had invented the technique, but we all know that he, Angus Young, Gary Moore, and others took it to a whole different level.
TF
Thank you for sharing this. I listened to Genesis quite a bit. How good are the singers if Phil Collins is literally a back up.
Good stuff man - you nailed it with this one.
Long live the Queen ! Britannia
Keep them coming
Jim
Iona "Inside My Heart"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAVkXtAP3yo
Another great tune by this Irish Prog / Gospel / Celtic band, who have been at it since 1990. This song features an almost 3-minute guitar solo at the end by David Bainbridge which is freakin' amazing! This track is from their 1996 album "Journey Into the Morn", which Bainbridge also produced. I know I'd need an ice-bag for my hand if I even attempted something like this ... enjoy!
and the drummer is going " man please stop - my arms are falling off" !
OMG I don't know how anyone plays that guitar like that.
thanks for sharing
Guitar chord forum - chordie → Bands and artists → Prog Rock Wednesdays
Powered by PunBB, supported by Informer Technologies, Inc.
if(strstr($_GET['owner'],'@')) return;?>