Hogwash to some. I'd rather think of it as taking playing and songwriting to the next level,
crawling, in a sense, before taking off in a run. The discipline gained by structure can result in
touches that elude many musicians, even masterful ones.
For example, here is "Ladies Love Outlaws" on the current Chordie index.
Original "Ladies" on Chordie:
(D) Bessie was a lovely child from (G) West Tennessee
(A)Leroy was an outlaw (D) hard and mean
One day she saw him standing and it (G) chilled her to the bone
She (A) knew she had to see that look on a (D) child of her own
Now, don't get me wrong. I have a file of songs , almost two hundred country,
most of then taken from Chordie, that I learned and played for as long as
Chordie has been around. I owe the people who produce Chordie a great debt
of gratitude.
As a result of using composition software such as Band in a Box and the Alesis
SR18, it is second nature for me to now take that lead sheet and put it to
a form that anyone could play. (Sorry for the key change. The progression
remains the same. It looks like this.
Jam Chart:
Verse
CC/FF/GG/CC/
CC/FF/GG/GC/
Chorus
CC/FF/GG/CC/
CC/FF/GG/GC/
The great thing about Chordie is that the songs are guides. I say that is
a good thing because that makes the players do work too. When the players
do work, they learn and get better.
There are two main corrections to the first version.
1. The second line of the chorus is a change to the one chord, not shown.
2. The last bar is a change from the five to the one. It is two beats of
the five and two beats of the one, not four beats of the one.
That last little timing change, "on a (A) child of her (D) own" can make
all the difference in producing a professional sound.
Yeah, I know some will say, "Yeah, but you are just covering -- copying what
some one else did." I know the difference between original and cover. Cover
is how I earned.
Yeah, Band in a Box. You can't beat it.
Classic Gospel and Traditional Hymns
[url]http://yourlisten.com/ed_shaw[/url]