canudigit wrote:You can say what you want but I am an expert and that's that. I bet I have been playing more years than you were born!
If this was an class on being an English major I might have used those COOL words, but I like to speak so others can understand.
The way you stated this previously is just another way of saying exactly what I said, just in a different way.
Well, no.
The measure of an expert is accuracy. And the statement "B up to the very next note is C and not B#," fundamentally, is wrong. It is *not* a basic rule. It is an artifact of how scales are built and is only true for certain keys. While in practical application on the fretboard (most of us will never use those keys where it is relevant) that does not make it "true."
Theory exists apart from any particular instrument. And as a science of intervals, we should try to be as accurate as possible in the words we use, so as to avoid confusion. This is particularly true when we risk propagating falsehoods learned by rote ("there is no B#") rather than understanding how scales are derived, and what that means for particular intervals.
The notes that "exist" are entirely dependent on the key that you play in. Sometimes B# is real. There are at least seven different modal scales that contain it derived from C# major.
If this were a class on theory, you would be marked wrong on your statement.