Baldguitardude wrote:I was suggesting that perhaps mozart and bach are more influential as composers, not musicians.
I would agree with this for the most part. Both were reputed to be monsters on the keys, but it's their compositions that live on. Franz Liszt suffers the same ignominious fate. Lack of recording technology really ruined a lot of old world rock star's reputations.
I would argue Rachmaninoff is the most influential composer and musician in that regard. We have recordings of him, and he is a master with both the pen and the key.
Jerome the note in blues that we play as a flatted third has an origin roots in field work songs where the blue note was less than a semi-tone flat of a natural third. We interpret it as a b3 because of how western music theory is notated (and because of fixed pitch instruments) but the origin of the note that makes up the blues scale is more like 1/2 way between a b3 and a natural 3.
So if I understand, the minor third in blues as originally sung in the fields was really sort of "flatted and a half" and we only play it minor due to the diatonic nature of modern music?
I suppose that makes sense. The music stemming from the African origins of slaves would lend itself to whatever modes African music is built on. I don't know much about the theory behind African music, but I would imagine that carnatic like scales with more than 12 tones would be in play.
Learn something new every day!