76

(34 replies, posted in Music theory)

Jerome

you're right. I thought the diminished included non scale notes but having checked its a perfect triad. just like you said.

how could I make such an error ?  is there something weird about diminished chords. or is it augmented chords that are weird. perhaps it just me smile

I should have said the vii chord is a diminished chord. its not much used in modern rock and pop so depending on your preferred style you may want to think about alternatives. a common substitute in Rock is to use a chord on the flattened VII note. In the Scale of G that is F major.


j

norm

your story reminds me of my very worst guitar experience under very similar conditions.  some friends came round to dinner and to cut a long story short by early evening they were sober and I was not. infact I somewhat beyond caring. it all seems to have gone very well. However but the next morning  I thought, ye gods, I butchered those songs on the guitar. ever since then I  never play after a drink. 
   

j

78

(34 replies, posted in Music theory)

my answer to the original question and the moment may well have passed is yes  the expected chords in the key of G are based on the scale notes 

however it is important to  note that ii, iii and vii chords are usually minor chords. 
so we have -

G Am Bm C D Em 

as to the Vii note, theres no chord which can be constructed on the vii note. some people use a dimished chord.  i tend to flatten the note by a semitone and play F. it works for me and is fairly common in rock   

by the way A#. I don't think so !  A whole tone up from A is B smile

79

(24 replies, posted in Music theory)

Bunglalow Bob

I was interested in your post.  Understanding and using chord progressions is extremely useful and I wish there were more postings on the subject

it does require some knowledge of Scales and how chords are constructed but those are only the basic building blocks of music. you can't do much with a scales and chords unless you understand some basics of harmony. 

its also really useful for song writing. infact while I'm not a profilic song writer I always start with a chord progression which I know work.

you can't go wrong with I  IV  V  I    smile

well okay, we know it get a bit tedious if all  pop songs used this trick but once you know the expected chords in a scale and a few progressions you can begin to experiment

it reminded me that ii and iii were minor !

j

80

(11 replies, posted in Chordie's Chat Corner)

I have come across this site. it plays random intervals and chords and encourages allows you to guess them. 

http://www.good-ear.com/

other things I am finding useful is harmonic theory. for those not familiar with the idea;  this is about taking the chords buildt on each  of the intervals of the scale and numbering them (usually with Roman Numerals). So C F G become  I IV V.  That  is in fact by far the the most common chord progression in the Key of C and its relatively easy  to memorise and recognise.

However  there are lots of other recognisable progressions. at the moment I'm just playing chord changes and listening to them.

81

(11 replies, posted in Chordie's Chat Corner)

Russell Harding - thanks. yes I may never be good.  I shall only aspire to get a lil' better. 

Daddy cool - I have a few songs with only four or five chords (passenger, best friends girl, knocking on heavens door,  so lonely, you really got me). I will try to work them out without the book open. any other tips for easy tunes would be gratefully received   

Selso - good tip. I shall try it.

Zurf -  ummmm. I've spent what seems like several  lifetimes playing scales and my ears are still useless. meantime my fingers have damn nearly fallen off. but thanks for the encouraging words. glad I'm not the only one who finds it tough.

alvee  - i so look forward to becoming a living guitar god. and only another 10,000 hours of practice to go !

Guitarpix - pleased that it worked  for you. I'll look out for it

82

(11 replies, posted in Chordie's Chat Corner)

i've been playing guitar for some years and can play most simple chord progression. i even picked up a bit of music theory. Harmony, Scales etc

however one thing I never worked out was playing by ear

some people seem to have a huge flair for it.  afterall there's folks who  transcribe music as a living and most players with experience seem to be able to pick up the basic chords of a song  but I seem to have cloth ears in that respect. i don't think its because I'm tone deaf. thats a medical condition but I can hold a tune to sing it.  i just can't turn that tune into notes and chords on the guitar

its a bit of disadvantage because it means I forget almost instantly all the songs in my "play list". the only song I can play from memory is Hey Joe by Jimi Hendrix and in case youre wondering thats without the solo. Just the chord progression. I only learnt it because I strum through the chords as soon as I pick up the guitar too check that its in tune. 

So what to do ? Thats the Question

I've put away all my tab and chord sheets and have my guitar in front of me waiting for tips

(I've already played Hey Joe) 

all suggestions welcome

83

(7 replies, posted in Electric)

i know what a difficult time you must be going through at the present time

I sincerely hope that you guitar makes a full recovery

I can also understand how very painful it can be having to open your wallet that wide

but you have to prepare youself for the worse - you will almost certainly have to buy a new set of strings too.

84

(2 replies, posted in Electric)

ahhhhh....... muting. there's an art

the best way to leran about muting is to watch someone do it. perhaps others can post some links 

but there are two basic techniques - right hand muting and left hand muting

starting with right hand muting (if you are right handed) - hope I've got this right -  yep just checked my guitar

youre playing barre chords or single notes. so instead of pushing down hard on the fret just press down until you get a slightly dull noise and voila a muted sound

but that would get a bit boring so the trick is to press down and release slightly. sometimes depending on the music and certainly if you want funky  this might be happening every second. now that is going to be hard until you've put in lost of practice and strenghened the finger muscles good. hope it doesn't hurt too much !

now left hand muting. basically you just touch the strings near the bridge to stop them ringing

sometimes just gentle resting on the strings but don't be afarid to give them a pecussive thump if youre doing a reggae or ska number

85

(13 replies, posted in Acoustic)

i think that they sometimes just shave the saddle a little

would they shave the nut (what for ?)
 
lowering the action in that way may may help you play better. a high action can make it hard to fret the strings.

however lowering the action too much will cause fret buzz so have it looked at by someone who knows about guitars

86

(7 replies, posted in Electric)

turn the amp up to 10 (yours might go uo to 11  smile )

do a couple of pentatonic runs and finish with some feedback

might just get away with it

i weas just watching kt turnstall perform black horse and cherry tree. it was on later with joolz holland a year or two back

she performs laregely unaccompanied but with a loop station or similar

excellent video on you tube

the writer of this song was John Newton. one of the things which John Newton felt strongly on his redemption was that people should show kindness to other including slaves and he was well able to talk about the subject having been a slaver. he wrote the lyrics at a time that slavery was being debated in England and it was abolished soon after. given its history the song was taken to heart by human rights activists and black gospel choirs.

the link with the police is rather different and I will speculate. The original tune to amazing grace has probably changed since it was written and there are various versions in existance. The most popular is based on the pentatonic scale and was possibly used by bagpipe players at or around the time it became associated with the song

it is also used by bugle players and has become part of the bugle repetoir. Bugles are associated with funerals. The military play "taps" but that is probably not fitting at a civilian funeral.  this may be one of the reason why the song which is not quite so military but evokes similar feelings is traditionally played at police funerals.

as I mentioned the tune is pentatonic which makes it ideal for arpeggios and for embellishment so its a nice tune for acoustic guitar

i might add feeder although there a bit older than the decade is

Here my ten  -

Linkin Park

Bloc Party

Dixie Chicks

The Killers

Razorlight

Blink 182

Queens of the Stone Age

Yeah Yeah Yeahs

The Gossip

Snow Patrol

91

(7 replies, posted in Chordie's Chat Corner)

For funk proper I suggest -

anything by The Meters

anything by James Brown

Theme from shaft - by Issac Hayes


and for alt funk

Been caught stealing - Janes Addiction

Start Chopping - Dinosaur Junior

Damaged Goods - Gang of Four

92

(3 replies, posted in Chordie's Chat Corner)

actually....

the chord changes are often in the the same place in second and third verses

song writers have to have lyrics which fit the underlying structure and rythym of the music

so if you keep on playing the music at the same tempo as in the first verse you may find that it fits

but listen carefully to how the lyrics are phrased, some words will be invariably stretched and some clipped slightly

sorry upyerkilt just realised that you said the same

93

(21 replies, posted in Acoustic)

and remember if you don't like the key its in try moving it. that gives you different chord shapes. chordie has a transposition tool which works on many songs . of course you have to stay within your vocal range but you might find that shifting key occasionally helps there too.

harmony central has a good community - if you need to know about fingering for jazz chords or the best way to use the dorian modes and you're on stage in 15 minutes its worth a look but

this is my favorite site by a mile.

95

(6 replies, posted in Acoustic)

you're a maestro for sure smile

try playing some bar chords with some left hand damping - great for funk reggae and ska

96

(9 replies, posted in Acoustic)

er, what video

gimme linx

cheers

97

(5 replies, posted in Electric)

the two effects are similar both in sound and in the nature of the effect

the flanger is more commonly used to create jet planes

phasers are often used to create more subtle effects

in truth most guitarists use both sparingly (unless your in hawkwind) so it might be worth considering a mulieffects unit. I think you can get both on affordable models.

otherwise try em at the shop

98

(2 replies, posted in Acoustic)

thanks guitar doc.

yes do what you want. but varying your strumming style can add interest to a piece and make it more obvious what you are trying to play

it sounds to me that rather than strumming randomly you already have three different and distinct strumming patterns.

I am interested that all your patterns have an odd number of strokes which suggests to me some varying in tempo within the pattern.

for example the second one is very popular for 3/3 time and waltz

1...2...3
V...V...n

but waltz time isn't very common in modern music so its more likely to be played like this -

1...2...3...4

V.......V...n

similarly the last pattern has five strokes but probably isn't counted as five equally space notes - it might be counted as follows

1...&...2...&..3...&...4...&...

V........V.......V.......V...n...

think about what you're doing - there are lots of other way to play the 3 patterns you suggested

and i suggest you try some simple alternate strumming - you might try eights -its a simple pattern which fits many modern songs and is good for rockier number

1...&...2...&...3...&...4...&...

V...n...V...n...V...n...V..n..
 
keep rocking...

99

(14 replies, posted in Chordie's Chat Corner)

I do have sympathy with the people of Tibet. There was a series of Free Tibet concerts recorded on a live disc.

try

bulls on parade (rage against the machine)

power to the people - john lennon and yoko ono band

rockin in the free world - neil young

clampdown - the clash 


having said that  -

I don't believe in boycotting the Olympics - world peace isn't well served by using international sporting events to score political points - the sporting community works hard to promote international relations.

100

(6 replies, posted in Electric)

i have joint problems if i play for long periods and press too hard on the fret board

spend some time with scales applying just enough pressure to fret the note

other tips

  - dont bend the heavier strings

  - use hybrid slinky or super slinky

  - don't play for long periods at a time