51

(11 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

Good advice above, but when you're in the shops don't restrict yourself to only playing guitars in your price range.  Play everything they have.  You're looking for an elusive combination of sound and feel, and when you find it, you might be willing to save up to get it.

52

(5 replies, posted in Music theory)

Practicing scales is also a good way to develop dexterity and finger independence.

53

(25 replies, posted in Acoustic)

I'll say it again: repetition.  Sing along with it on the iPod, play along with it with the fakebook in front of you, run through it a couple of times a day (especially those odd licks and fills that you've never tried before), play it SLOWLY to lock it into your fingers with no mistakes.  Once the fingers know the song, it frees up your brain to get stuck on the lyrics wink

I have a list of about 60 or seventy songs that I have learned at one time or another; but I only have about 35 or 40 "under my fingers" currently (I started lessons again recently, and some of my repertoire practice fell by the wayside).  I have binders full of the lyrics and chords, and as Butch8844 said, the problem is keeping them sorted.

54

(18 replies, posted in Electric)

Yes, my Precious, you have drunk the Kool-Aid...

55

(18 replies, posted in Electric)

I had a bit of a "warming up" period with mine; time and a bit of modding have made my 5122 second only to my 6120TM in my hands and heart.  Flatwound strings (I use Tomastik-Infeld JS-111's) and a Tru-Arc bridge make a very good guitar one of the best, IMHO.

Enjoy your new friend.

Also, if you become a Gretsch True Believer (I did!) you can find lots of great information, and one of the best discussion forums anywhere, over here:  http://gretschpages.com/

56

(14 replies, posted in Acoustic)

I generally practice for 2-1/2 to 3 hours a day; more on weekends.  What I practice changes, in that I only practice a single thing (skill, technique, riff, what have you) for about 5-10 minutes at a time, and then move on to something else.  I've been doing this for almost 3 years now.

By the way, practice most emphatically does NOT make perfect.  Perfect practice makes perfect.  The guy above who recommended practicing slowly hit the nail squarely on the head.  The goal here is to take your mind out of the equation, and we do that through muscle memory, basically teaching your fingers the skill in question.  Thing is, they don't know when something is "right" or "wrong", they can only do what they have already done (over and over and over).  If you take the time to do something slowly enough that you NEVER make a mistake, your fingers will dutifully reproduce it as you get faster.  Soon (relatively speaking), you're playing at performance speed with no mistakes, and your conscious mind is out of the loop.  When you start doing it, it's kind of spooky; sometimes it becomes a bit of a trick to keep your mind "out of the way" and just let your fingers go!

So, what I do:  1) have a list of things to practice (written or mental, just know what you're working on); 2) go so S-L-O-W-L-Y (I'm talking mind-numbingly slowly) that you make no mistakes (for guidance here, see Jamie Andreas' "The Principles of Correct Practice for Guitar"); 3) Use a metronome; 4) record yourself, so that in a few months you can listen and see how far you've come.  You only need to record yourself once a week or so, date the tapes or files, then go back and listen in three or four months.  You will be amazed.

57

(18 replies, posted in Electric)

I'm not familiar with the Ibanez; I started playing seriously about 3 years ago, and stumbled onto the Gretsch 5120 shortly after (the 5122 wasn't in production yet).  I fell in love with the look, feel, playability and sound and I've been a Gretsch guy ever since smile  One caution: the Electromatics are a gateway drug; you will soon be GASing for a Pro line.

Another advantage of the Electromatics is their moddability, if you're into modding at all, there are tons of (relatively) inexpensive options for making the guitar your very own.

58

(18 replies, posted in Electric)

The 5122 isn't a semi hollow, it's a full hollow body with a sound post.  A semi-hollow is like a Gibson 335 or an Epiphone dot, which has a plank down the middle.

There is nothing currently on the market which can compare with the 5120/22 for value for the dollar, IMHO.

59

(148 replies, posted in Acoustic)

Another tip on the perseverance front: get yourself a cheap audio recorder (I used a Sony microcassette that cost about $20) and record your practice sessions for a week or so.  IF you practice consistently EVERY DAY for two months, then go back and listen to those tapes, you will be astounded at how far you've actually come.

I've been playing and practicing for an average of three hours a day for the nearly three years now, and whenever I get a little discouraged, I think, "where was I six months ago?"  I'm always miles farther along than I was then.  The key is doing it consistently every day, at least six days a week; to pay attention to what you're doing, and to do it slowly enough that you don't make any mistakes.  Once you teach your fingers what they are supposed to do, they will take over and just do it.

Something I meant to point out earlier about barre chords, is to practice them first well up the neck; around the ninth fret or so.  It's MUCH easier to play them up there, and as you get more confident with them, move them gradually down toward the headstock.  You'll be playing both the B and the F in a month.

Welcome to Chordie, Caromshot.

60

(148 replies, posted in Acoustic)

That's the essay I was looking for yesterday and couldn't find.  Thanks.

I put a tuner on my Taylor and my Gretsch this morning, and I did find that I'm pulling the f# chord just a touch sharp, but that might well have been finger position (not quite getting the barre right over the fret).  I say that because both the G and the F were right on, so I don't think there was a significant amount of neck flex involved.

I hope that everyone else has been reading and benefiting from this discussion, Guitarpix.  It's important that the attitude toward barre chords shifts from dread to anticipation; these forms are absolutely essential to a lot of material, and make so much of it so easy!

61

(148 replies, posted in Acoustic)

...And I'm all about less fatigue and easy stretches! 

The only effect I use with any regularity is a bit of reverb, otherwise I'm playing clean.  I also have a solid-wood Taylor acoustic (they don't get much lighter than that!), I'll check with the tuner on that too.

I was just digging around, trying to come up with the Guitar Principles term used for what I'm trying to describe for the barres, and it's "the heavy arm"; meaning that if you use the muscles in the fingers to keep them just stiff enough, you use the large muscles of the arm to apply pressure to the strings.  The Principles also has exercises to teach just how LITTLE pressure it actually takes to fret a note, so that might be a factor as well.  Somehow, I knew that I wasn't the first one to come up with this...

62

(148 replies, posted in Acoustic)

It might come down to differences in the ears and the instrument; I'll freely admit that my ears aren't the most sensitive in the world.  smile  As to the instrument, I'm playing on Gretsch archtops in classical position, with the back snugged right up to my chest and my right forearm naturally rests across the "corner" between the side and top of the lower bout (I'm also doing mostly fingerstyle these days, for what that's worth).  With an archtop electric, suppressing some of the 'liveliness' of the guitar is pretty well necessary for controlling feedback.  Plus, I really like the feeling of the guitar back vibrating against my chest, but YMMV. 

I came up with how to do this a couple of years ago, when I was struggling with barre chords and thumb cramps on a daily basis.  I was watching some concert footage, and asking myself, "how do these guys make it look so easy for so long?"  At the same time, I was working through "Principles of Correct Practice for Guitar" (which I highly recommend to everyone, by the way), and the muscle and touch-awareness that is put forth in that book suddenly just clicked -- use different, stronger muscles to do the same job.  Suddenly, the chords were ringing and I could do it for 10 minutes straight from the get-go.

I don't have a guitar with me at the moment, but I'll slap a tuner on and check it tonight when I get home.  Gretsches have pretty narrow necks (not so narrow as a Rickenbacker, but still), so it ought to be detectable.

Just curious here, how do you keep the guitar away from your body when you're playing?

63

(148 replies, posted in Acoustic)

Guitarpix wrote:
dguyton wrote:

Barre chords are very nearly effortless when done right.

First, leave your comfort zone.  If you normally practice sitting down, stand up (or vice versa).

Second, the effort for the barre chord DOES NOT come via the thumb!  Your finger muscles are used to hold your fingers in position, and the effort on the strings comes from the shoulder and bicep.  You'll need to put some counter pressure across the body with your strumming/picking forearm, and getting comfortable with that takes practice.

Once you have the idea, you can actually lift your thumb from the back of the neck, and still play the barre chord!  Your thumb is only used as guide at that point.

If you're not working on this stuff for 5 minutes, every single day, then you're slacking. Quit your whining, and do the practice. ;-)

This method does make it much easier but using the guitar as leverage also pulls it sharp about 1/8 -1/4 note by pulling the neck back. Try holding your guitar with a tuner in your lap... Now position your finger to barre the lower 5 strings but don't apply any pressure. Hit the E string and it shows in tune, now barre the lower 5 strings ( allowing the E to ring through) using leverage like that and watch the E move to sharp. I'm not sure how much or even if it really does hurt it, but I wouldn't think that that constant flexing of the neck joint would be good for the guitar in the long run either.... Just some thoughts....

Guitarpix, that would be true if you were using more pressure than it takes to make the strings meet the fret.  If you're using the right amount of effort, it's absolutely no different than using just the fingers, you're just using bigger muscles to do it.  I've NEVER pulled it sharp this way.

64

(148 replies, posted in Acoustic)

Barre chords are very nearly effortless when done right.

First, leave your comfort zone.  If you normally practice sitting down, stand up (or vice versa).

Second, the effort for the barre chord DOES NOT come via the thumb!  Your finger muscles are used to hold your fingers in position, and the effort on the strings comes from the shoulder and bicep.  You'll need to put some counter pressure across the body with your strumming/picking forearm, and getting comfortable with that takes practice.

Once you have the idea, you can actually lift your thumb from the back of the neck, and still play the barre chord!  Your thumb is only used as guide at that point.

If you're not working on this stuff for 5 minutes, every single day, then you're slacking. Quit your whining, and do the practice. ;-)

65

(1 replies, posted in Electric)

I have a first generation G-Dec, and have found it to be useful; I don't think I would try gigging with it.  There is a lot of information available here:  http://mygdec.com registration required, but it's free.

Sounds like you might be interested in something like this:  http://www.folkofthewood.com/page5308.htm

It's a flatpicking technique called "crosspicking" and can be quite useful.  While there isn't any video on the site that I'm aware of, there's plenty of tab to get you started.

67

(4 replies, posted in Electric)

I've given this a lot of thought, and I'm going to go with I-IV-V.

68

(4 replies, posted in Acoustic)

I have never notice any day-to-day improvement in my playing, and I practice about 2 hours a day, six days a week.  You see the improvement when you look at what you are doing now as compared to six months ago.

69

(13 replies, posted in Acoustic)

Actually, your current fingering will help you out later when you start working on barre chords.

70

(12 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

Fred Kelley Speed Picks.  Look here:  http://www.fredkellypicks.com/products-page/speed

Z, it's not so much that you learn the alternate fingerings first, then go after the barre's; you learn the alternate fingerings when you learn the barre's, and then they are available to you whenever you need them.  I almost never use the "three finger" A chord shape anymore; I figured out how to do the A-form barre with the middle and index fingers, and now I can use just the middle finger to make the A shape -- much easier, faster to change to and from.

The MOST IMPORTANT THING to remember when learning barre chords is not to try and clamp the chord with your thumb.  That will only lead to pain (oh, so much pain) and frustration.  Your thumb is just a guide.  Keep your fingers stiff and pull the chord in from your shoulder, using your arm.  Barre chords are almost effortless, once you learn how to do them RIGHT.

One of the things that distinguishes a "more advanced" player from a "beginning" player is the ability to use alternate fingerings, to not lift fingers that you don't have to, and not to place fingers that you don't have to (all aspects of the same thing, really). 

If you want to learn barre chords (and you do, so much music is vastly easier using them), it really isn't that big a deal to learn to place the 2nd, 3rd and 4th fingers.  Once you have those down, the alternate fingerings will be useful in the rest of your playing.  I find myself fingering chords in different ways depending on what I've just done and/or what is coming up all the time, and it really isn't something that I have to think about at this point.

73

(4 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

Got me, I've never played a LP.  However, since matching the string arc to the fretboard radius on my Gretsches, I don't plan on looking back anytime soon.

74

(4 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

What you're having problems with is the mismatch between fretboard radius (which has nothing to do with setup, it's a manufacturing decision) and the flat profile imposed on the strings by the tunamatic bridge.  Fortunately, there is a solution.  There is a product known as a "Tru-Arc (tm)" bridge (which is a modification of the Gretsch "Rocking Bar Bridge") that can match your string radius to that of your fretboard.  You will need to know your fretboard radius, and send an email to Tim Harman (harmanz (at) psci (dot) net).  The bridges come in brass, aluminum, or stainless steel, and different materials will affect your tone in various ways; Tim will be happy to work with you and determine exactly what you're after.

Disclaimer:  I am not affiliated with Tim or Tru-Arc in any way, other than being a satisfied customer.  I just ordered my fourth bridge from him last week.

75

(2 replies, posted in Guitars and accessories)

Clean (clear) channel as opposed to distorted channel; think Chet Atkins sound, where you can pick out the tone from each string, vs. Jimi Hendrix.  Many amps offer a both a clean and a distorted (or dirty) channel, so that you can play different styles through the same amp just by pushing a button.

Likewise, some pickups distort better than others (single coils generally have a 'dirtier' sound than humbuckers).  Pickups are wound 'hotter' (more windings) by some makers, or with larger gauge wire.  Some are hand wound vs. machine wound.  Some are active vs. passive (you're going to have to google that one, I don't know from active pickups).  In this case, there are NOT just a couple of makers and different marketting.

Buying online: today, most guitars parts are built by computer controlled CNC machines, only the final assembly is done by people, and therefore the consistency from instrument to instrument is much better than when everything was done by hand.  For this reason, if you are buying a reputable brand from a reputable dealer, there really isn't much danger to buying online (ebay is a different story).  However, I always recommend building a relationship with your local shops--service is better, you get to try first, and you can frequently negotiate a better deal than you can get from online retailers.

That's all assuming that you're buying a pretty standard instrument.  Vintage or custom shop instruments are a whole 'nother ball of wax.