He seems really overwhelmed... so I'm REALLY glad I'm doing some research so I can steer him in a good direction. So far this is what I've got for an "electric guitar primer" ... let me know if I'm wrong!
1. a solid body guitar should be made of SOLID wood... no laminate... not two different types of wood for the face and back
2. alder would be the best choice if you can choose a wood???
3. for an electric that will "play anything" ... look for 2 single coils and one humbucker pu
4. the 5 way switching seems to be a good option to go along with those pick ups
5. don't need to get fancy with the amp if you're just playing in a house filled with 4 other people (2 are under 5 years old)
6. in the case of #5 headphones are a necessity and a practical "surprise" gift to go along with the guitar and amp
7. Ibanez makes great guitars... however they tend to be tricky on the fretting hand
8. If you can afford it buy a Fender or a Gibson
9. If you can't afford it... you can always upgrade the set-up and still have a great guitar (in many cases)
10.Made in Mexico is better than Made in China in a lot of cases
Ok... so that's what I've got THUS far. Again, let me know if I'm wrong on any of these points! LOL! A lot of the points there I've gotten not just from reading your suggestions, but they've been seconded elsewhere on the web (so you guys do know what you're talking about!). Of course, the NUMBER ONE rule of buying any guitar should always be to try it out first, that one goes without saying.
So my last question. He said something about going to the local music shop and maybe buying a used guitar. Something nicer than the Squire for the same price. Now... I know the local music shop is going to know the value of these used guitars and they aren't going to just let someone get a "steal" in. Should I expect that if he does find something he likes there... that it will have been gone thru? (at one of the shops my feeling is yes, at the other my feeling is no) Should I expect that the pickups will need to be maybe changed? Should I expect that we'll have to shell out a little extra to have it gone thru and set up? I'm a little leary about that. I'm thinking he'd be better heading into a pawn shop or on ebay to buy something used at more of a "steal" and THEN pay to have it gone thru and set up. Personally... I'd prefer if he just bought a "starter electric" and get to know it... THEN plan on spending $500 NEXT year once he knows what he's doing! I'm a bit cautious about him finding something he THINKS he wants and spending a huge chunk on it and then wishing he'd waited till he knew better. I feel like I'm talking about a little kid here not a grown man... but really... he's a beginner and doesn't know what he "needs" just "wants". I won't throw out a man slur here, because ALL adults can act like kids sometimes!
I'm no expert on this either but I do love your idea of surprise headphones for Christmas. Just make sure he doesn't crank it and go deaf or he'll never hear you when your........
No problem there... he's good at toning me out already Kenny! We've been together 10 years in February (married for 7) ... so he's a pro at that! LOL!
I haven't been able to find anything out about these online. Can someone lead me to their websites?
'm no guitar tech but I took it home and did a set up on it and was blown away at how much it sounded like my American standard Strat.
Yep... I've heard a LOT of that... with the right set up the Squire's sound awesome... some have great reviews right out of the box like that one Fat Strat I mentioned earlier. I'm really hoping he goes that way... but in the end it'll be up to him of course!
I might suggest taking afew hours or days at guitar dealers and trying some models out.
That's what I want to do... BEFORE we put the money together and actually KNOW the exact amount that is really going to get spent... to just try a bunch of them out. When we bought my classical we were just planning on trying a bunch out. I picked up $1000 guitars... $700 guitars... $99 guitars... and in the end settled on a "starter" that cost about $150... I actually liked how it felt and sounded more than the more expensive ones! Low and behold we had the cash and purchased it that day cuz I fell in love and we DID have $150! I really want him to just go and try a bunch of them out before he does much more looking online and tries to fall in love with the LOOKS of one!
THANKS everyone for your help!