Thanks for the comments about "Moderation", for which I was recruited not that long ago. The standards as explained to me seem quite reasonable, and I personally don't think Chordie is over-moderated ... but obviously that line is going to be in different places for each person.
a) I think we'd agree that spammers promoting health products, insurance, etc. don't belong here
b) I certainly hope we're not advocating for members bashing one another because they don't measure up to our performance standards musically, or personal musical tastes
c) I hope we won't promote financial snobbery, by looking down our noses at what kind of gear some can afford
d) Regarding profanity and adult-content, I would hope we'd want musicians of all ages & sensibilities to find Chordie a comfortable place to be
There's enough tension, confrontation, anger, and hate in the world around us. Surely we don't need to bring those things into something as benign as a musicians' discussion forum ... do we? If these are thought to be too rigid, then perhaps I've misunderstood something, and I'm certainly open to guidance.